Britax vs Diono – Who makes the best car seats?

britax vs diono comparison

“Was that a spin ride, mommy?”

 

Little did he know that they have just been in a horrible accident.

The scariest part of an accident is that you are powerless. The only thing to do is hope that all the safety measures are enough. This is why it’s paramount to get the best protection for your kids.

Since we are the parents, we have to look out for them. Accidents can’t be predicted. You can only be prepared for them.

Look:

To get the best car seat for your little one, it’s no small task. It takes days and even weeks to go through all the information. There are many brands with so many models.

That’s why I’ve created this comparison between Diono and Britax. By reading this to the end, you will know exactly which brand is the smart choice. Not only that, but you will know which car seat will suit you the best.

Stick with me for a bit, and you will find out everything there’s to know about the crash I’ve mentioned above. I will share with you which car seat was involved and how it has performed.

I had to stray away from my traditional comparisons because Diono doesn’t have such a variety. To keep it apple to apples and orange to oranges, I can only compare two car seats. This is the only way I can keep this vs article fair.

The two categories that I compare are the convertible and the all in one car seat. Let’s see how this plays out.

 

Britax vs Diono Convertible Car Seat

Convertible car seats are the first ones on my list. Since Diono doesn’t have such a huge variety, I’m trying to put a square peg in a round hole. Convertible car seats have two functions they can be used in rear-facing mode and front-facing mode. It’s highly advised to keep your little one in rear-facing mode as long as possible.

From Camp Britax, we have the Marathon ClickTight, and from the Diono camp, we have the Rainier 2AX.

Britax Marathon vs Diono Rainier 2AX

Direct Comparison Diono vs Britax Convertible Car Seat

Britax Marathon Diono Rainier 2AX
VS Britax Marathon Convertible Car Seat Diono Rainier 2AX Convertible Car Seat
Safety SafeCell Tech
Steel Frame
Side Impact Protection
5-point harness
Full Steel Core
SIP
Energy Absorbing Foam
5-point harness
Size Limits Rear Facing 5-40
Front Facing: 20-65
49”
Rear Facing: 14-50
Front Facing: 20-65
49”
Installation ClickTight Super Latch
Fabric/Material Machine Washable Machine Washable
Cup Holder 1 Flexible
Recline Position 7 2
Headrest Position 14 12
Rethread Harness
Extended Use
Price

Britax Marathon ClickTight Short Review

Britax Marathon ClickTight Convertible Car Seat

The incident happened with some friends of ours.

They were on their way back. Their 13-month old was sound asleep in the back. They almost made it.

When the accident happened, the father could see beyond the cure. There was a huge puddle of water. When he noticed it was too late. The car hydroplaned off the road into the tree. The impact totaled the car instantly.

Not only that, but the SUV wrapped around the tree. The frame of the SUV was twisted so much that it was unrecognizable. All the windows were blasted into small pieces. The airbags did their thing and protected the parents.

When everything was over, they checked on their little one. He was fine. While the parents got a few injuries, the little boy was safe and sound.

The Marathon has done an excellent job keeping the little one safe. If you check out the safety features, you know what went down.

This car seat has both front and rear-facing mode. The biggest difference between the Diono is that you can use the Diono longer in the rear-facing mode. The upper limit is set to 50 pounds. Experts recommend keeping your child in this mode as long as possible because this is the safest.

This car seat caters to newborns as well because the lower limit is set to 5 pounds. Thanks to the ClickTight tech, the install is so easy. All you have to do is pop the seat and use the latch or the seat belt. Once you here the seat click, you’re done.

 

Diono Rainier 2AX Short Review

Diono Rainier 2AX Convertible Car Seat

My friend was traveling with her son. It was their normal daily commute. That day was different.

They were crossing a busy intersection when an inattentive driver T-boned their car. The impact was big. It has totaled two cars instantly. The metal bent into an odd shape. The windows cracked and exploded into a million deadly shards.

It wasn’t over yet. The impact was so big that it spun the car around.

The little boy wasn’t even aware of the danger. When everything settled, he asked if this was a spin ride—the innocence of kids.

He was the lucky one. The Diono Rainier car seat did its job and protected him from harm. His mother wasn’t that lucky. She walked away with a shoulder injury.

These two car seats look the same. The biggest difference would be that the Diono caters to toddlers and beyond. Plus, it has a minor flaw in the installation department. To get it right, you will have to work at it. You have no choice but to climb in the car and push down the car seat and wiggle plus pull to get it tight. There’s a steep learning curve with this seat.

Other than that, the secondary features are weaker than the Britax. It has fewer options for recline, and we all know that’s the only way to avoid the head slump.

My biggest issue was the rethread harness. I don’t like it when you have to manually adjust it because I could never get it right.

 

Which convertible car seat is better?

They are so close. The winner is the Britax Marathon because it’s easier to install, and you don’t have to rethread the harness.

 

Britax All in One Car Seat vs Diono All in One Car Seat

This is the second category where I’m making a comparison. All in one car seats are for those parents who plan ahead. They rather pay more upfront than get a new car seat at every stage. In the long run, this is a real money saver. There are a few drawbacks which I will detail below.

From Camp Britax, we have the One4Life, and from the Diono camp, we have the Radian 3RXT.

Direct Comparison Diono Radian 3RXT vs Britax All in One Seat

Britax One4Life vs Diono Radian 3RXT

Britax One4Life Diono Radian 3RXT
VS Britax One4Life All-in-One Car Seat Diono Radian 3RXT All-in-One Car Seat
Safety SafeCell Tech
Steel Frame
Duo Guard Protection
5-point harness
Full Steel Core
SIP
Energy Absorbing Foam
5-point harness
Size Limits Rear Facing Mode: 5-50
Harness Mode: 22-65
Booster Mode: 40-120
63”
Rear Facing: 5-45
Front Facing: 20-65
Booster Mode: 50-120
62”
Installation ClickTight Super Latch
Fabric/Material Machine Washable Machine Washable
Cup Holder 2 Built In 1 Flexible
Recline Position 9 2
Headrest Position 15 12
Rethread Harness
Price

Britax One4Life Short Review

Britax One4Life Car Seat

Britax has brought its A-game with this car seat. Taking your newborn home from the hospital until they get their driver’s license, it will serve your child well.

The car seat is based on a steel frame. This will keep your little one protected no matter what. The SafeCell tech absorbs the impact energy, and it doesn’t travel up into your child’s body. The side protection is getting important as the years go by. With Britax One4Life, you’re getting two layers of side protection.

With this car seat, you will be able to do extended rear-facing. The upper limit is set to 50 pounds. Since this position is the safest, no wonder, you have this much room to grow.

I can’t get enough of the ClickTight tech. It made the car installation a breeze. All you have to do is pop the seat feed through the latch or the seat belt and then close it.

When it comes to comfort, Britax delivers. This car seat offers nine recline positions. So no matter if you have a newborn or a toddler, they will be able to sit and sleep comfortably in this car seat. Manually rethreading the harness is my kryptonite. Luckily when you adjust the headrest, the harness is adjusted as well.

 

Diono Radian 3RXT Short Review

Diono Radian 3RXT Car Seat

It was an ordinary errand run for the family. The father was driving and the little one is sitting right behind him in the car seat.

Then it happened. An inattentive driver hit them from the side in an intersection. The crash came from the driver’s side, exactly where the child was sitting.

Metal screeched and bent. The glass has shattered. You lose all control in an accident. There’s nothing to do then brace for the impact. I hope for the safety features to keep you protected.

The van’s front side got wrecked. It was a small miracle that nobody got hurt. The small boy was safe and sound. There wasn’t even a scratch on him.

The Diono Radian did an outstanding job of protecting the child. Since it’s an all in one car seat, this is the first and last car seat you will ever buy. This caters to infants up to young adults. At first glimpse, there’s not much difference between the two car seats.

The Britax has a bit higher size limits here and there. The safety seems equally strong for both of them. The installation is straight forward; you can use the latch system or the seat belts. All you have to do is feed the straps through the belt guides, and you’re done. Since there’s no helping mechanism, you might work up a sweat getting it tight.

In these cases, I look at the secondary features. We can see that the Diono falls short in two categories. First, it only offers two reclines positions. This is important because this makes the car seat comfortable. Plus, if the car seat is sufficiently reclined, it protects the child from the head slump.

The second biggie is that you will have to rethread the harness.

 

Which All in One Car Seat is better?

The Diono tried its best, but it has fallen short. The winner is the Britax One 4Life.

 

Car Seat Buyer’s Guide

I know how long and hard it is to find the perfect car seat. This is why I’ve put together a micro buyer’s guide.

Check out my tables above, and you will see what the most important features you should check are. First up is safety. The more protection a seat offers, the better. Initially, there was just front and rear crash protection. As time went on, they started paying attention to side impact protection. Now a few car seats offer safety against rollover accidents, which are the deadliest from them all.

Next thing, you should check what the size limits are. The more you can use a car seat, the less you have to pay in the long run. I call this mileage.

The third most important thing to check with car seats is how easy or hard is the installation. Always check with your manual first, then go on and find videos. I’m highly skeptical of the brand made videos. They make it look way too easy. The reality can be found on YouTube.

The last important item on my list is the material. Now we’re talking about kids so accidents and spills will be common. You will have to know how easy it is to remove the cover and wash it. Some brands only allow spot cleaning, while others allow machine washing. All have their pros and cons.

After I’ve gone through these in detail, I look at the secondary features. Sometimes there are gold nuggets and something they are a nuisance. This is why it’s so important to check them out. Also, when you’re reading reviews, do take them with a grain of salt.

It happened to me countless times when for the same car seat, I’ve found two radically different reviews. One said that it’s impossible to install, and the other said it’s a breeze.

Now, this would be my micro guide for getting the best car seat.

 

Conclusions

We have reached the end of this Diono and Britax comparison. Diono tried its best, and finally, Britax came out as the winner.

By now, you should know which brands are the right choice. Also, by reading the micro-reviews, you should know which car seat is the right fit. Now it’s your turn. Get the car seat that you feel is the right fit. Get it soon because last time I checked stocks were running low.

If you have tips or ideas, share them below.

Catch you next time!

Britax One4Life ClickTight All-in-One Car Seat – 10 Years of Use – Infant, Convertible, Booster – 5 to 120 Pounds - SafeWash Fabric, Drift
  • 10 years of use: New one4life convertible to booster car seat grows with your child from 5 to 120 pounds & up to 63 inch tall
  • Install confidently: With a ClickTight installation, you'll know it's right in 3 easy steps
  • One4life: Converts from rear facing infant car seat, to forward facing 5 point harness, to high back belt positioning booster
Diono 2019 Radian 3RXT All-in-One Convertible Car Seat
  • JOY OF THE JOURNEY: From birth, keep your little one rear-facing longer to 40 lbs., and as they grow to 100 lbs. (10 years approx.) our long-range lifespan protects your child facing-forward.
  • THREES NOT A CROWD: For safety that fits 3 across the Radian 3RXT packs all our innovative safety features into a sleek and slim design that allows you to fit three across (in most mid-size vehicles). Now the whole family can travel, together
  • LOVINGLY ENGINEERED: The Radian 3RXT is built with automotive-strength steel, engineered into a dual spine, which manages and dissipates energy with an unyielding structure to protect your baby. Our audible click SuperLATCH system makes installation easy

 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ):

Is Diono a good brand?

Yes, Diono is a great brand. Price-wise they are OK. They have over-engineered the safety which is a good thing.

What is the best Diono car seat?

By far the Diono Radian 3RXT is the best car seat from Diono. It’s versatile and it will be the first and last car seat that you ever have to buy.

What is the difference between Diono Radian RXT and 3 RXT?

The difference between the Diono Radian RXT and 3 RXT is minimal. The Diono Radian 3RXT is the latest version of the Diono brand. They have made mostly cosmetic changes.

Diono vs Britax car seats can you fit three across?

Diono is known for making narrow car seats. So yes you can fit three across with the Diono Radian RXT.

Diono vs Britax infant car seat are there other competitors?

Yes, you can go with clek fllo or Nuna rava. It’s important to know that both Britax and Radian infant seats come with an infant insert. The seat cover is nice and plush. Plus the seat cover can easily be washed.

Diono seats vs Britax what are the weight limits for the booster seats?

The typical weight limit is 120 pounds for a booster seat. The highest rear-facing weight limit is 50 pounds. Make sure you check the back seat limitations.

Diono car seats vs Britax seats what kind of safety features do they have?

Besides being easy to install the Diono comes with a metal alloy frame. The crash test results were impressive. For added recline, you can use a pool noodle. Both car seats are filled with eps foam so the impact energy gets dissipated. The chest clip is easy to use. There’s more than enough legroom for the child and the first row.

Britax seats vs Diono which one has the best installation features?

By far Britax ClickTight has the easy installation. You can use either the seatbelt installation latch installation to get the seat tight. All you have to do is to connect the latch connectors to the latch anchors. With the harness height adjustment, the headrest is done as well.

 

Last Updated on September 9, 2020

Last update on 2020-10-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

About Danny Reid
About Danny Reid

Danny here, no matter in which market you’re in it’s flooded with products. Maybe you want a new stereo, amps, speakers or subs? This is why the blog exists to cut through the clutter.
My goal with the reviews is to inform you of the best possible to make the right decision.
Plus if you’re stuck with “the blue wire is connected to???” I have many hot tips to get you out of a jam.